Let’s face it, folks. You could be exploring new worlds, embracing thrilling plot twists, or expanding your cinematic horizons. Instead, here you are, curled up on the couch with the Gilmore Girls or popping in Home Alone for the gazillionth time. If this sounds like you, don’t worry—you’re not alone in this ritualistic plunge into the comforting abyss of nostalgia. But why, with streaming services practically begging us to try something new, do we keep going back to the same shows and movies like moths to the warm glow of a well-worn television screen?
Experts have weighed in on this phenomenon, because apparently, watching Elf every December isn’t just a cozy tradition—it’s a matter of psychological survival. Let’s unpack the science, the sentiment, and the sheer laziness behind our love for rewatching old favorites.
The Control Freak's Paradise: Why We Love Predictability
Here’s the deal: life is unpredictable, chaotic, and, frankly, exhausting. Bills, work emails, and surprise phone calls from your kid’s school secretary don’t exactly scream “I’ve got this under control.” Enter your favorite show or movie—a perfectly scripted sanctuary where you know every line, every joke, and precisely when Kevin McCallister is going to scream his head off.
Media psychologist Pamela Rutledge explains that rewatching old favorites lets us manage our emotional state by eliminating the possibility of surprise. No plot twists here, just the warm hug of already knowing what happens. You’re not watching The White Lotus wondering which character is going to bite the dust—you’re watching Lorelai Gilmore banter at lightning speed about coffee and snow.
Let’s be honest: the holidays are stressful. But knowing that Clark Griswold will still light up his house like a lunatic in National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation? That’s a reassuring constant in a world that feels like it’s held together by duct tape and wishful thinking.
Saving Mental Energy, One Rewatch at a Time
Dr. David Spiegel from Stanford says old habits conserve mental energy. Translation: You’re too tired to learn a new show’s character arcs, conflicts, and thematic nuances. Who has the bandwidth for another binge-worthy drama when you’re already juggling work stress, PTA meetings, and the mystery of why your dog keeps eating the Christmas ornaments?
When you rewatch something, you’re giving your brain a break. No stress, no problem-solving—just you, Home Alone, and the smug satisfaction of knowing exactly when Marv is going to get smacked in the face with a paint can.
Think of it as comfort food for the mind. Sure, kale smoothies are new and exciting, but mashed potatoes have never let you down. Similarly, you could take a chance on the latest critically acclaimed Netflix drama—or you could press play on Friends and let the laugh track do its thing.
Nostalgia: The Gateway Drug to the Past
Ah, nostalgia—the emotional equivalent of digging out your old high school yearbook and realizing you peaked during your sophomore year. For many of us, rewatching A Christmas Story or It’s a Wonderful Life is less about the plot and more about the memories. These aren’t just movies; they’re time machines.
Rebecca Tukachinsky Forster, a media psychology professor, points out that revisiting old movies connects us to our younger selves and to the people we shared those experiences with. Remember sitting on the floor in your SpongeBob pajamas, surrounded by wrapping paper, as The Grinch blared in the background? That’s the feeling you’re chasing when you hit play today.
Sure, your current reality might involve inflation, gray hairs, and an inbox full of spam emails, but for 90 minutes, you’re back in a simpler time. A time when your biggest worry was whether Santa got your letter—and not whether the Wi-Fi bill autopay went through.
Escapism 101: Losing Yourself in Simpler Times
Let’s call a spade a spade: the world can be a dumpster fire. Between the 24-hour news cycle, social media doomscrolling, and your cousin Chad’s 97th Facebook post about his cryptocurrency hustle, sometimes you just need to unplug. And what better way to do that than by revisiting a movie where the biggest drama is whether Ralphie will shoot his eye out?
Holiday movies in particular are the holy grail of escapism. Pamela Rutledge explains that their simple plots and happy endings offer us a temporary reprieve from the soul-sucking monotony of adulthood. You don’t have to think, you don’t have to stress, and you certainly don’t have to question why the Hallmark Channel pumps out 137 new Christmas movies every year. You just let the predictable joy wash over you like eggnog for the soul.
Your Favorite Characters Are Basically Your Imaginary Friends
Ever feel like you know Rory and Lorelai better than you know your neighbors? Or that you’d genuinely prefer to have dinner with Harry, Ron, and Hermione than your actual coworkers? Congratulations, you have what psychologists call a “parasocial relationship.” It’s a fancy way of saying you’re emotionally invested in fictional characters who don’t know—or care—that you exist.
When you rewatch a show or movie, it’s like visiting old friends. Rebecca Tukachinsky Forster likens it to the warm and fuzzy feeling of reconnecting with someone who hasn’t changed at all. Unlike your actual friends, who might have moved away, changed jobs, or suddenly decided they’re into CrossFit, these characters are always right where you left them.
The Health Benefits of Shameless Rewatching
If anyone dares to mock your 47th viewing of The Holiday, you can hit them with this: science says it’s good for you. That’s right—rewatching your favorite shows and movies isn’t just an indulgence; it’s practically doctor’s orders.
1. It’s a Self-Soothing Tool
Rewatching something familiar is like wrapping yourself in an emotional security blanket. Tukachinsky Forster says these familiar characters and stories can help us recharge and cope with life’s daily stresses. So go ahead and let Mr. Bean ruin Christmas dinner for the hundredth time—you’re self-soothing like a pro.
2. It Releases Feel-Good Chemicals
Did you know just anticipating a rewatch can boost your mood? Pamela Rutledge explains that the anticipation triggers your brain’s reward system, releasing dopamine—the chemical responsible for feelings of pleasure and satisfaction. So when you’re gleefully counting down to Love Actually night, you’re actually giving your brain a little chemical pick-me-up.
3. It’s Good for Your Physical Health, Too
Positive emotions don’t just make you smile—they literally lower your blood pressure, reduce your risk of heart disease, and can even help you live longer. So the next time someone tells you rewatching The Office for the 18th time is “lazy,” just remind them it’s essentially cardio for your soul.
The Snarky Bottom Line
So here’s the deal: rewatching your favorite movies and shows isn’t lazy, uninspired, or an admission of defeat. It’s a survival strategy, a health regimen, and a sentimental time machine all rolled into one. Sure, you could watch something new and edgy, but why risk disappointment when you can revisit the comforting absurdity of Die Hard (yes, still a Christmas movie)?
And let’s be honest: life is short, and there’s only so much energy to go around. If rewatching Gilmore Girls or Home Alone for the hundredth time is what gets you through the chaos, then by all means, press play and revel in your nostalgia-fueled bliss. Who cares if you know every line? That’s not just familiarity—it’s mastery.
Black Friday Sale - 10% OFF Your First Order